Books That Broke My Spirit: 2011
I try not to just give up on books. In fact, I probably ought to quit more books and not waste my time, but. . . I just don’t.
Still, every once in a while, a book just doesn’t do it for me. These are the fifteen books I gave up on in 2011 (theses are books that I was committed enough to put in Goodreads as “currently reading” and then finally gave up. There are, I’m sure, other books that I picked up, read a page or two, and never picked up again. But they aren’t on this list).
- The Chronicles of Harris Burdick – Someday I will just learn that I hate short story collections and to stop wasting my time on them. Amen.
- Miss Peregrine’s Home for Peculiar Children – I was listening to this and I think this is one that might need to be read instead of listened to. But it’s hard to pick up a paper copy of a book you already have bad feelings toward. So, despite this being on all of the best-of lists this year, it might just be one I skip forever.
- Girls in White Dresses – I tried. It annoyed me. I gave up.
- The Last Anniversary – I loved What Alice Forgot so much that I immediately picked up another book by the author, got confused by the number of characters in the first chapter and didn’t bother to return. I am lazy.
- The Notorious Benedict Arnold: A True Story of Adventure, Heroism and Treachery – I renewed this one six times but I just never actually finished it. It was interesting, but not the one I was dying to finish. Clearly.
- Walden, or Life in the Woods – My goal was to read four classics this year and this was going to be on of them. I picked something less dense and with more of a storyline instead.
- Work Hard, Be Nice: How Two Inspired Teachers Created America’s Best Schools – I listened to this (it’s about the KIPP schools and how they started) and I just couldn’t make any progress. It went on and on.
- The Time-Traveling Fashionista – This is one I actually might come back to. But I just haven’t been hooked yet.
- One Day and One Amazing Morning on Orange Street – I tried so hard on this book (which I got from The Picnic Basket) but. . . I couldn’t do it.
- The Pioneer Woman: Black Heels to Tractor Wheels – My tolerance for the number of times an author can describe how weak her knees went is about 3 times. I listened to this at double speed while I was on the treadmill for 30 minutes (so about 60 minutes of listening) and I heard it no less than 15 times. It was absurd. It embarrassed me too much to continue.
- The Cinderella Society – I can remember exactly nothing about this book except a keychain. It was due back at the library and I sent it back without hesitation.
- The Replacement – This book gave me the creeps. I don’t do books like this.
- The True Meaning of Smekday – Everyone raved about how amazing this book was, especially the audio version, but it did nothing for me. I guess I don’t like weird alien voices?
- Juliet – Too long and too silly. I gave up after 50 pages. My mom read it and said that giving up was a good plan.
Anybody else toss a book (or twenty) to the curb this year?


I admit its been awhile since I perused blogland so I don't even know how long you've had this new look…. but I LOVE it!
Hey! I just noticed you changed your blog! I like it, very clean.
I gave up on Love in the Time of Cholera and it took me about 2 years to fully get through Wicked. Once I got to the middle, I loved it, but some parts were just so blah to me.
A) Love the new blog layout/format/look. Tres chic!!
B) I have the Pioneer Woman book, but I also hate repetition of adjectives/adjective phrases…hrm…something to think about. Moving it down on my "To Read" pile.
xox
I adored you for many reasons, but your willingness to admit to NOT finishing books clinches the deal. There are just some books that are NOT WORTH IT.
Of course, I did take your "I should just learn I don't like short story collections…" comment as a challenge.
Here are three short story collections I HIGHLY recommend. Perhaps you have read them/tried to read them and decided they sucked, but I am hoping you haven't and that you DO read them and love them as I did:
Civilwarland in Bad Decline by George Saunders
The Girl in the Flammable Skirt by Aimee Bender
A Good Man Is Hard to Find by Flannery O'Connor
I tried to read The Great Gatsby this year and just got to bogged down. I want to, I really do but I may not be a classics girl.
Aww, I loved Juliet! But the three people I recommended it to all thought it was silly, so I might be alone in that.
The Pioneer Woman's book was better when it was just a series of posts on her blog. I'm a lot more forgiving of repetitive goofiness in a blog post than in something published and professionally edited.
And according to Goodreads, I gave up on 46 books this year, which is a lot more than I thought! The worst was Prom and Prejudice by Elizabeth Eulberg, which tries too hard to reproduce P&P in a modern Gossip Girl setting and ends up making Lizzy a shrew and Darcy a pushover.
I try so hard not to give up too. I think it was 5 or 6 this year, but I probably should have given up on more 🙂