I am a self-admitted awards junkie. I love reading a book with a shiny sticker on the front – Caldecott, Printz, Newbery, National Book Award, Morris Award, I love them all. Do not even ask me about my spreadsheet of award winners/nominees/honors that I check off as I read them. It’s too embarrassing.

But my favorite award doesn’t hand out stickers. You may not be familiar with the Cybils awards; they haven’t been around since 1938 like the Caldecott (or even longer for the Newbery). They began in 2006, as a set of awards given out by book bloggers for juvenile and young adult books. Anyone (and I mean ANYONE) can nominate a book in any of the nine categories. Then a group of first round panelists for each category read all the nominees and come up with a list of seven finalists. A second group of judges then chooses a winner from those finalists. The finalist lists and the winners tend to be terrific, terrific books.

The point of the Cybils is to select books that have “high literary merit” AND “kid-appeal.” I love them for this. You may notice, if you ever look closely at the criteria for the ALA awards like the Caldecott and Newbery, that “kid-appeal” appears nowhere within them. And sometimes the winning books are staggeringly unappealing to most children. I have a lot of personal librarian angst about this topic; for every Tuesday by David Wiesner (a book I have yet to see a child not fall upon eagerly), there are a dozen . . . well, lets not name names here. We’ll just all agree that there are plenty of Newbery, Caldecott, and Printz books that most kids would be pretty skeptical of.

It’s been really fun to watch these awards gain momentum. When we went to DC for the National Book Festival, Shannon Hale’s bio mentioned that her books had been Cybil winners. Didn’t THAT just warm my heart?

This year, I’m a judge on the non-fiction picture book category. Between now and the middle of February, our group will pick a winner from the seven finalists that the first round judges selected. I’ve been collecting the titles from the library and they all look terrific (you can see them all here: Non-Fiction Picture Book Finalists).

I am so excited to be part of the process this year – I can’t wait to see what the winners end up being. And then, when the judging is all over, I’ll add another tab to my Nerd Spectacular Spreadsheet.

You Might Also Like


  • Reply Shelly January 7, 2010 at 2:02 pm

    Oh, that is SO COOL! And yes, kid appeal should be a MAJOR component of those awards. I can remember some picture books that were winners that totally left me cold. So I get your point here.

  • Reply megan January 7, 2010 at 2:26 pm

    Wow, that's fun! And a very useful category for my six year old who loves non fiction. Some of the ones we've seen…well, they had some appeal to him I guess, but to who else? I am excited to check out the finalist list.

  • Reply Packrat January 7, 2010 at 3:11 pm

    Kid appeal – that includes nice covers, too. I know we were told to never judge a book by its cover, but which books do most children (and adults) pick? If there are two copies of the same book side by side, the one with the colorful cover will be the one picked out almost every single time.

  • Reply Jess January 7, 2010 at 4:27 pm

    This is awesome! And so perfect for you. Have fun!

  • Reply Jenny January 7, 2010 at 5:34 pm

    oh, phew!
    I thought you were going to allude to psycho-cases with spinning heads…
    What a COOL category of awards!
    Have FUN~

  • Reply Yankee Girl January 7, 2010 at 7:29 pm

    That is really very cool. And all the books looks so good and I feel very smart for having read one of them already–the Carmen Deedy one which made me cry just a little. Also, (not that I am trying to influence your vote) I think that Carmen is such a lovely and funny woman (I drove her around the Timpanogos Storytelling Festival and she was just such a delight–not all of them are).

  • Reply Heather January 7, 2010 at 7:37 pm

    will you send me the list too? I love book lists. I'm also looking for good books to read with my 6 1/2 year old boy. Out loud that will be fun for both of us.

  • Reply Slice of Pink January 7, 2010 at 9:11 pm

    Very exciting!

    P. S. I sent you a very important email! =)

  • Reply Melinda January 7, 2010 at 10:19 pm

    That is so fun!!! Congratulations on being a judge! Can't wait to see what books make it this year!

  • Reply Abby January 9, 2010 at 1:17 am

    Hmmmm, note to Cybils organizers: design stickers. I'd certainly purchase them to put on the books in my library's collection!

    (And I don't envy you the job you have ahead of you as a judge – I don't know how I would choose between those books!!!)

  • Leave a Reply