Recently, the second To All the Boys I’ve Loved Before movie came out and so the topic of book to film adaptations has been on my mind.
And double so, since also seeing Little Women recently.
It can be SO easy to be super bugged by a film adaptation of a book you absolutely love, but naturally, if it’s a book you love, it’s hard to NOT want to see the film adaptation.
Here are a few tips to make it more fun to watch book to film adaptations:
5 Tips for watching Book to Film adaptations
- Don’t read the source material RIGHT before you see the movie. When I saw the first To All the Boys I’ve Loved Before movie, I hadn’t read the book in about a year and I LOVED the movie. It was just utterly delightful. Six months later, I re-read the book and then immediately watched the movie and enjoyed it much less because allllll the scenes and dialogue from the book were fresh in my mind and it was so hard not to miss everything they had to leave out of the movie.
- Keep your expectations reasonable. Go in with an open mind and know that some things will be left out, some people won’t look like how you imagined them, and that sometimes the plot will be changed in big or small ways. Bart and I say all the time “good expectations are the key to happiness” and nowhere is this more true than in a book to film adaptation.
- Treat the film adaptation as a separate work. If you expect the movie to be just the book word for word on the screen, you’re absolutely be disappointed. And even if they DID do a completely perfect replica of the book, would it even be any good? Just like you’ll be super disappointed in a brownie if you expect it to be a cookie, recognize that they’re both chocolate (the same story) but different ways of bringing it to life. Don’t expect every scene to be perfect or it to be exactly what you imagined when you read the book – just enjoy it for what it is.
- Recognize what a movie adaptation can bring to the table. A movie can do lots of things that a book can’t do, like music, detailed costumes and sets, and sharing it with someone else. Focus on the things a movie does well instead of the things it can’t replicate from a reading experience.
- Consider watching the movie FIRST. I know this is heresy to some readers (my mom, for instance), but if you watch the movie first, then you get to experience the longer, more detailed version afterward, instead of seeing a compressed version of the story after you’ve had the full book experience. The only downside here is that your mental images will definitely be guided by the movie and actors.
Any other tips for watching book to film adaptations without being outraged by what’s different or left out?
If you liked this post about watching book to film adaptations, you might also like these posts:
Thanks for this! My 10 year old has a book she loved so much and found out it has a movie, but all the reviews said it deviated from the book a lot. This gives me some ideas on how to encourage her to enjoy the movie too.
I usually like to read the book first, but last night we watched The Good Liar (Helen Mirren and Ian MacKellan). I’m looking forward to reading the book next to fill out the story even more. (I feel like the movie didn’t connect some things, to the extent that at the end, I was “HUH?” about one of the major plot points.)
I read crazy rich asians about 6 months after having seen the movie and was fairly frustrated with both the book and the movie because it deviated so much (the endings are different) but I ended up reading the whole trilogy and after having read them, I was much more satisfied with the movie. Basically, the story was a super complex one and I think there would have been huge issues to try and convert the whole trilogy to movie so the way they changed the first one for the movie made much more sense and was more satisfying.
Janssen Bradshaw says
I didn’t read the book, but I LOVED the movie and I heard from many people that they liked the movie more than the book!
Torrie @ To Love and To Learn says
What did you think of the second To All the Boys movie? The actor they got to play John Ambrose was sooooo different from how I pictured him that it was a little disconcerting to me the whole movie. I actually remember liking the second book better than the first, but with the movies, it was the opposite—I loved the first movie, and the second was just okay. Still excited to watch the 3rd, though!
Janssen Bradshaw says
Oh, man, I LOVED John Ambrose in the movie – I thought he was the PERFECT cast. So perfectly charming but so different from Peter. All my thoughts about the movie here: https://www.instagram.com/stories/highlights/17880299617516316/
Thank you for this article. I love reading books after watching a film about it.
Kathy Hill says
Your tips are spot on! I have not seen the latest movie version of Little Women yet, and I’m anxious to re-read the book, but I’m not going to do that until after I see the movie because I know I will be disappointed.
Case in point, my hubby and I watched Ready Player One, and thought it was fun, and decided to listen to the audiobook. After we finished we watched the movie again, and didn’t enjoy it nearly as much!
Want to talk about heresy? I like the Lord of the Rings movies better than the books — I know.