Book Reviews

Okay for Now by Gary D. Schmidt

April 6, 2011

I don’t have words to praise Okay for Now highly enough – I have had to curb myself considerably to keep from quoting nearly the entire book in this review. I worried that there was no way it could live up to The Wednesday Wars, which is perhaps my favorite book of all time, but it was just as wonderful.

I really think Gary Schmidt might be the best middle-grade author alive today. His books have everything – brains, wit, humor, heart.

Okay for Now is a companion book to The Wednesday Wars, but most definitely not a sequel. If you haven’t read The Wednesday Wars, you won’t have that unpleasant sensation of missing a lot of things as you read Okay for Now (oh, how I loathe that feeling). This truly is a stand-alone book.

Doug Swietek appears in The Wednesday Wars, but he’s notable mostly for his list of  “401 ways to make a teacher hate you” and his older brother, known only as “Doug Swietek’s brother”  who is, himself, a notorious trouble maker and always out to get someone (often Holling).

Now, Doug gets an entire book to himself. As it opens, his family is moving away to Marysville where his dad has gotten a new job (no one dares to ask about why he’s lost the old job, but Doug’s descriptions of the family make it clear that Doug and his older brother didn’t inherit their trouble-making ways from nowhere). The new house is a complete dump and Doug has to share a room with his older brother who has “quick hands” (both the stealing and hitting kind).

And thus begins life in “stupid Marysville.”

The first day there, Doug finds himself in the library, where, in an empty upstairs room, is a book under glass, open to a picture of a bird drawn by John James Audubon. The picture completely arrests Doug; his interest is noted by Mr. Powell, an older librarian, who takes it upon himself to break down Doug’s walls a little and teach him how to draw.

These informal art lessons are a bright spot in Doug’s fairly dark life. He’s keeping secrets about his family, which you discover quickly when he describes his older brother (who, like Holling’s sister in The Wednesday Wars, remains unnamed for a very long time) stealing his Joe Pepitone hat and “pummeled me in places where the bruises wouldn’t show. A strategy that my . . . is none of your business.” And he has a job delivering groceries on Saturday mornings but his customers are extremely wary of him after a break-in that most of the town believes was done by his older brother. You can imagine why the quiet of the library and the patient teaching of Mr. Powell have such appeal to Doug, even if he wants to pretend they don’t.
In the same way that the works of Shakespeare acted as a narrative guide in The Wednesday Wars, John James Audubon’s art is the continuous thread in this book. If you’d told me that beforehand, I would have been wary, since I’m not particularly artistically inclined, but it worked marvelously.

In The Wednesday Wars, Holling describes the lesson where Mrs. Baker is teaching about diagramming sentences and the sentence Doug gets is “I read a book,” which, as Holling notes, “was a flat-out lie on Doug Swieteck’s part.” And the academic problems that Doug clearly had at Camillo Junior High are even more present in Marysville, where the teachers are disinclined to like him from day one because of his family’s reputation:

Miss Cowper in English, whose first words were “This fall, we will be reading Jane Eyre by Miss Charlotte Bronte, and I am not naive enough to believe that you will all like it.” Then she looked right at me.

And while we are on the topic of Jane Eyre, let me mention that it, like the Audubon paintings, plays a major role in the plot. At the risk of spoiling something, let me tell you that when, on the airplane to Utah, I read the line “Reader, I kissed her. A quiet walk back we had, she and I,” I almost leapt from my seat with delight.

Like The Wednesday Wars, this is a book that defies a tidy description. It’s about art and Audobon’s birds, it’s about people who can only see the “skinny thug” who comes from a problem family and the occasional insightful person who is able to see past the label to the real Doug, it’s about soldiers returning from the Vietnam War to a place that no longer seems like home, it’s about families where no one discusses real problems and you hide anything you value so it doesn’t get mocked or destroyed or both.

And yet, for all the sadness of this book, the humor is there in full force. I found myself marking line after line that made me laugh. A few examples because I can’t not share. The first is during a wrestling unit in gym class, led by “the So-Called Gym Teacher” who hates Doug:

He said he’d call out the names two by two, starting with the first pair to wrestle. Guess who was in the first pair. My partner turned out to be Alfred Hartnett. I’ll let you guess again: do you think Alfred Hartnett weighed about the same as me, or about sixteen times more?

And while Doug makes Saturday grocery deliveries:

Mrs. Daugherty was keeping my bowl of cream of wheat hot, and she had a special treat with it, she said. It was bananas. In the whole story of the world, bananas have never once been a special treat.

And he handles the intense moments just as well as the humor. When there is a particularly ugly conversation at dinner one night:

There’s a kind of angry quiet that can lay down over a house. Maybe there are some houses, like the Daughertys’, that have never known it – that house probably hasn’t ever had a quiet day. But in the The Dump, Angry Quiet was an old friend, and he moved in again. No one talked because we all wanted to scream.

This book is so brilliantly written, so full of depth and beauty that any adult will love it. But it’s so full of heart and humor and real-life that children will love it too. Read this book. Your life will be better for it. I promise.

Digital copy obtained from NetGalley

You Might Also Like


  • Reply Tina's Blog April 6, 2011 at 11:26 am

    I agree…..I LOVED it, too.

  • Reply lifeofadoctorswife April 6, 2011 at 1:38 pm

    You are SUCH a good reviewer. I want to go read it immediately.

    The subject matter – the juxtaposition of really hardcore issues with humor – reminds me of books like "There's a Boy in the Girls' Bathroom" and "Maniac Magee." Makes me want to go reread those immediately as well.

  • Reply Maggie April 6, 2011 at 4:14 pm

    I LOVED The Wednesday Wars! I had no idea there was a book about DOUG! YAY!

  • Reply Lisa April 6, 2011 at 5:14 pm

    I added this to my Goodreads list, but who knows when the library will spring for it.

  • Reply Nemesis April 6, 2011 at 6:26 pm

    My library has this one on order & I just put my name on the holds list!

    Loved Wednesday Wars. Loved, loved, loved.

  • Reply Mia April 6, 2011 at 11:39 pm

    Okay okay… I wasn't interested when I saw it on your list the other day… but you've sold me, on both books. I'm going to give it a go!

  • Reply Rachel April 7, 2011 at 12:26 am

    I cannot wait to read this! I'm #1 on the hold list at the library- hooray!

  • Reply Carol April 10, 2011 at 2:37 pm

    I agree with you about Gary Schmitt. Amazing! Read this book in one night!

  • Reply Ms. Yingling April 12, 2011 at 9:24 am

    I worked on this for over two months and still couldn't get through it. Thanks for the positive review.

  • Reply Kathleen May 30, 2011 at 6:33 pm

    Just read this yesterday and I LOVED it. I'm not so good at reviewing books…but your review does a pretty great job of it (even had me tearing up as I remembered certain parts). Never would have known this was out there if I hadn't seen it on your goodreads, so thanks!!

  • Reply Angela Noelle of SK April 12, 2013 at 5:35 am



  • Leave a Reply