Book Reviews

Bella at Midnight by Diane Stanley

December 2, 2007

I first heard about the Texas Blue Bonnet Award when my in-laws gave me The Goose Girl last year and the back mentioned it was a Texas Blue Bonnet Book. I looked into it a bit, but never quite understood how the system worked.

A few weeks ago, while walking through the children’s section of the library, I noticed that there was a shelf dedicated to Texas Blue Bonnet Books. Above the shelf was a large poster giving the names of all the Texas Blue Bonnet Books for the 2007-2008 year. I picked out two of the books and came home determined to figure out what this whole Blue Bonnet Books thing was about (could I possibly use the term “Texas Blue Bonnet Books” any more? No).

It turns out that the Texas Blue Bonnet Book list is put out every year – the 20 or so books on the list are chosen by a committee from nominations that can be made by an Texas librarian, teacher, student, or parent. Once the list is published, libraries and schools can purchase the books and encourage students to read them. The books must be by a U.S. author and published in the last three years. The books can be of any genre and either fiction or non-fiction. The tag line is “Read Five and Decide.” Students are encouraged to read five of the books (any five) and then vote for their favorite one. At the end of the year, the book with most votes is bestowed the Texas Blue Bonnet Book Award.

Anyway, Bella at Midnight was one I picked off the shelf basically at random. I’d never heard of the author or the title. It’s touted as a “Cinderella story” but it’s only marginally so.

Bella is born to a knight and his wife; unfortunately, the wife dies within a day of Bella’s birth and Bella’s father (Edward) demands that the child be taken away, for he cannot bare to see her. Bella’s aunt, Maud, takes her to the home of a blacksmith in a nearby town; the blacksmith’s wife has just finished acting as a wet nurse to Prince Julian who lives with his uncle at the castle in the village, and she agrees to take in Bella.

It soon becomes clear, though, that Edward has no intentions of ever coming for Bella, even after she no longer requires a wet nurse and so the Blacksmith’s family raise Bella as their own, never telling her that she is not really their daughter. Bella grows up happy and loved, and develops a close friendship with Prince Julian who often comes down to visit the family and play with Bella and her older “brother,” William.

The kingdom, however, is at war with the neighboring kingdom, and several times raiding and burning parties come through and level the village while the villagers gather in the palace for protection. Finally, though, the Hundred Year War comes to an end and a treaty is signed. Part of the treaty is that Prince Julian will go live in the court of the former enemy. He leaves just after an unfortunate incident between himself and Bella where he publicly snubs her for fear of being ridiculed by his friend. He is horrified by his behavior, but has no opportunity to make things right before he is whisked off to the other kingdom.

The story’s focus switches to a woman and her two daughters. Her husband has been lost at sea, and all their riches lost. In desperation, she marries Edward who now sends for the Blacksmith’s family and demands his daughter be returned. Bella is horrified to find that her “family” is not really her family and that her father is cold and perhaps a bit mad. Her new step-family is equally unkind to her and she retreats to the kitchens where she works with the cook (having grown up in a working family, she is more used to servant’s labor than genteel living, after all).

Then, one day the older step-sister returns from her position as queen’s attendant at court and gleefully informs her mother that the queen and king are not speaking because the king has decided to attack the former enemy (and break the treaty between them) in order to expand his holdings and make a great name for himself. Of course, since Julian is stationed at the palace, it’s likely he’ll be a casualty. But no matter – there is glory and riches to be had. What is one little brother in the grand scheme of things?

Bella is horrified and determines to travel to the other kingdom and warn Julian. Despite his brief unkindness to her (and her fear that he never really cared for her, but only thought her a silly peasant girl), she feels certain she must at least attempt the journey.

I thoroughly enjoyed this book – the writing was excellent (it reminded me of Shannon Hale) and the plot moved right along with enough twists and turns to keep you guessing.

The book also has multiple narrators – nearly every character is given a chapter in which to tell a bit of the story from their own view. I think in some books this would be distracting, but it worked really well in this book, I thought.

Additionally, this book is quite religious. Again, in some books this might have made me uncomfortable, but the author handled it very deftly. It didn’t seem overt or out of place, but easily it in the flow of the story. Even if you weren’t religious, I don’t think it would be bothersome as a reader.

Anyway, it’s a great book, and I’m pleased to see that Diane Stanley has written a number of other books.

You Might Also Like


  • Reply chloe elizabeth December 3, 2007 at 12:04 am

    Thanks for sharing this one. I will have to check it out for my tonsil removal period.

  • Reply Karen December 3, 2007 at 2:55 am

    Sounds fun. Utah has a similar book award program, and I have found a number of good books that way.

  • Reply Melanie December 3, 2007 at 3:21 am

    I haven’t really spent much time reading children and young adult books, but you’ve made this one sound really good. It’s now on my Christmas break reading list. Thanks!

  • Reply Noelle December 3, 2007 at 1:51 pm

    Did anyone else notice the Bella/Edward similarity to the Twilight series? Hmmm….

  • Reply Miriam Higginson December 3, 2007 at 5:19 pm

    I,too, was going to mention the Bella and Edward thing, yet again in a good book!

  • Reply Terri B. December 3, 2007 at 7:59 pm

    Janssen, Have you read Shannon Hale’s newest book, Book of a Thousand Days? I just got my hands on it and can’t wait to read it!

    I’ll have to check out this one you reviewed. It sounds good.

  • Reply housewife December 4, 2007 at 2:40 am

    me too me too! What’s up with the Bella Edward thing? Janssen – any similarity to Twilight?

  • Reply Anonymous December 27, 2008 at 5:29 am

    i really enjoyed reading bella at first i didnt think i would like it but it ended up being a very good book.

    i also noticed the belle/edward similarity but their is a diffrence than it was in thw twilight series

  • Leave a Reply